Players report that Big Bad Buffalo is a visually appealing slot game that immerses them in a rugged, Wild West environment. The game features a 5x4 reel setup, which some find refreshing compared to traditional layouts. The community finds the free spins feature particularly exciting, as it can lead to substantial wins, especially when combined with the buffalo wild symbols that expand and create winning combinations. However, some players note that the base game can feel somewhat repetitive, and the frequency of triggering bonus features can be inconsistent. Overall, Big Bad Buffalo offers a solid gameplay experience with the thrill of potential big wins, but it may not hold the attention of players seeking constant action.